Blog

Brandon Rozek

Photo of Brandon Rozek

PhD Student @ RPI studying Automated Reasoning in AI and Linux Enthusiast.

On Writing Simple Scripts

Published on

2 minute reading time

I generally prefer a simpler solution to a problem if possible. This comes especially true with scripting. If I write a small script for something like say my website I generally have three requirements of the system:

  • No dependencies outside the language
  • Language is interpreted (I don’t want to worry about build dependencies)
  • Comes preinstalled on systems I care about

I primarily work on Linux systems and very rarely don’t. Therefore, the simplest scripting language for me to write in is Bash. In fact, I generally reach for that first. If what I need to do is sufficiently complicated, then the next language I’ll reach for is Python.

Though that begs the question, what is sufficiently complicated? Here are some tasks that I don’t think Bash is suited for:

  • Data Parsing
    • I know ack, sed, and grep exist, but they’re complicated and unintuitive to use. We write programs for people first, computers second.
    • Harder to parse JSON. The program jq exists but that’s not part of the GNU coreutils.
  • Math
    • I believe bc is the easiest command to use to process arithmetical expressions. Though this also then involves constructing strings to pass into bc. For example: result=$(echo "1 + 5" | bc)
  • Anything requiring abstract data types
    • (Associative) arrays in bash are scary to me
    • Slawomir’s functional programming in bash library makes it more bearable. (My fork)
  • Argument Parsing

So why Python?

  • Comes preinstalled on most Linux systems as they’re often used in desktop environments
  • Currently has developer mindshare so others are apt to understand the scripts

Both those reasons are likely to make it so that my choice will change over time. Perl used to be the very popular choice for scripting…

Reply via Email

Have you published a response to this? :